Excess Carbon Dioxide and Plant Biology: A Pandora’s Box

Episode 38 of Unconfined, in which Lewis Ziska, a plant physiologist and professor at Columbia University, shines a light on how excess carbon dioxide in our atmosphere affects plant biology—which affects nutrition, which affects public health.

Carbon Rich, Nutrient Poor
By Christine Grillo Subscribe to Host Notes
In the latest episode of Unconfined, plant physiologist Lew Ziska, a professor at the Mailman School of Public Health at Columbia University, told a story about one of my favorite plants, goldenrod, Solidago canadensis. He loves it for the same reasons I do. Aside from being beautiful, it’s one of the last sources of pollen and nectar for pollinators at the end of summer. The nectar provides carbohydrates—energy—and the pollen provides protein and other nutrients.
When Ziska was at USDA back in 2016, he and colleagues from other universities and the Smithsonian Institution got their hands on historic specimens of Canada goldenrod from the U.S. National Herbarium collection at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History. The samples dated back to 1842, before the Industrial Revolution. They compared the historic samples with pollen from field trials simulating varying levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide, and what they found is that as levels of carbon dioxide increased, protein content in pollen decreased.
“That’s worrisome,” said Ziska, “because when you start looking at bees, that’s a keystone species.”
And yes, this finding does have implications for humans.
Quick plant biology note: Plants use nitrogen to break down carbon dioxide, which combines with sunlight and water to create sugar and carbohydrates. As carbon dioxide increases, the plant uses more nitrogen to break it down—which means less nitrogen is available for plants to use. Nitrogen is essential to creating protein.
So, what Ziska and his colleagues are finding is that some species of plants used for food are providing less protein for humans and other animals today than they did 100 or 200 years ago—and that is most likely because of excess carbon dioxide.
That is a big problem for public health, says Ziska, because one of the plants affected by this phenomenon is rice. More than half of the world’s population relies on rice as a major staple food. In 2018, Ziska and colleagues found that rice was affected by higher carbon dioxide levels to this extent: protein levels declined by about 10 percent, iron by 8 percent, and zinc by 5 percent. The team also found that certain B vitamins declined significantly, some by up to 30 percent. And this is in a world where already two billion people suffer from micronutrient deficiency.
“That’s not good,” says Ziska.
He and colleagues have been looking at the effects of excess carbon dioxide on plant chemistry since the 1990s. Carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has been steadily increasing since the Industrial Revolution—and remains on a steep upward trajectory. “I think it’s gone up by 30 percent since 1975. And it’s going to go up another 50 percent by the end of the century,” Ziska says.
This isn’t just a rice problem, either. The same is true for other staples such as wheat, barley, soybeans, and potatoes. It creates what Ziska refers to as “hidden hunger,” a condition in which people don’t necessarily feel hungry but are not getting the nutritional integrity that their bodies need to function well.
“So, what do we have?” he asks. “We have a plant that is carbon rich but nutrient poor.”
He is especially concerned about nutritional deficiency for children and pregnant women, as well as the one billion people in the world who depend on plants as their primary source of medicine.
The fossil fuel industry does a great job of spinning excess carbon dioxide as a positive. Ziska paraphrases the industry: “CO2 is plant food! It’s wonderful! It’s great! It’s going to provide the next Garden of Eden!”
Indeed, in 2017, former Representative Lamar Smith (a Texas Republican), wrote an article in which he said that, “A higher concentration of carbon dioxide in our atmosphere would aid photosynthesis, which in turn contributes to increased plant growth. This correlates to a greater volume of food production and better-quality food.” He must not have read Ziska and team’s 2016 research.
(This was the same article in which he exclaimed that melting Arctic sea ice would create new shipping lanes, strengthening the world economy.)
But what if, in the new Garden of Eden, for every oak tree there is also a super-powered poison ivy or invasive vine? As Ziska says, there’s “a whole Pandora’s box” of what excess carbon dioxide will do to plant biology, human nutrition, public health, and everything in between.
Listen to the episode to hear Ziska say more about the urgency of this problem, the mixed-up priorities of the media, the sad state of research funding, and what are and are not good uses of research dollars. “Don’t get me started on Golden Rice” might be my favorite quote from the episode.
In Host Notes, the voices behind Unconfined podcast deliver additional context to supplement our interviews. Their views do not necessarily reflect those of the Johns Hopkins Center for a Livable Future or the Johns Hopkins University.